Protecting the consumer's right to choose alternatives for simplicity, dignity, and economy in funeral arrangements


FCAI News

Our 2014 newsletter is available online, and our annual comparative price survey of funeral services has been updated.

Your Funeral Consumer Rights in Idaho

The Funeral Ethics Organization offers the pamphlet Your Funeral Consumer Rights in Idaho, summarizing your rights in making funeral arrangements, choices for disposition of remains, veteran and Social Security benefits, and the pros and cons of prepaying for a funeral. The PDF is available via that link at no charge.

News and information of interest

Funeral poses mimic life

It's not for every taste, but an idea that picked up steam in Puerto Rico in 2008 is catching on, with the enthusiasm of a New Orleans funeral director "thinking outside the box." Rite of the Sitting Dead: Funeral Poses Mimic Life (June, 2014)

Best and worst things to say to someone in grief

Among the resources at grief.com, suggestions for the best things to say to someone in grief (and what not to say).

DIY Death

From Boston's WBUR Natural, At-Home Funerals And Their Boomer Appeal:

"[I]n most states it's perfectly legal to care for your own dead. And, with new momentum to shatter longstanding taboos and stop tip-toeing around death — from "death with dignity" measures sweeping the country to projects promoting kitchen table "conversations" about our deepest end-of-life wishes — a re-energized DIY death movement is emerging." (Nov., 2013)

A funeral doesn't have to cost $10,000

FCA Executive Director Josh Slocum featured on LifeHacker: You Don't Have to Spend a Ton on a Funeral--Here's Why (May, 2013)

Don't put off "the talk" with your parents

From the New York Times "Your Money" section: The Talk You Didn't Have With Your Parents Could Cost You (May 24, 2013)

Discussing end-of-life care

Health care reporter Charles Ornstein found his thinking about end-of-life care challenged by his mother's death. (NPR, March 1, 2013)

Regulating cemeteries

The FCA's executive director Josh Slocum spoke in the 60 Minutes segment describing problems from a lack of regulation of cemeteries in this country that aired on May 20, 2012: Final resting place: Cemeteries lack oversight. More information and related links are on the FCA "Daily Dirge" blog.

Regulating the trade in caskets

How 38 Monks Took on the Funeral Cartel and Won, by Conor Friedersdorf, in The Atlantic. "Their victory in federal court means they can sell caskets without a license—and has implications for entrepreneurs all over the United States."

George Will offered further opinion (Washington Post, Nov. 14, 2012) about the history of restraint of trade, and the "dishing out [of] special economic benefits" as the 10th Circuit appeals court put it in 2004 (on the way to supporting state and local governments' prerogative).

Preneed funding facts by state

The Funeral Ethics Organization has compiled preneed funding facts specific to all 50 states and the District of Columbia. We've added their pamphlet, Pre-paying for Your Funeral in Idaho, to our publications list.

Guide to cemetery purchases

The FCA's pamphlet, A Consumers Guide to Cemetery Purchases is available as a free (PDF) download.

Laughing matters, maybe

Who says the folks in the funeral industry don't have a sense of humor? MortuaryMall.com announced a "Black Friday" sales event. The offerings include "industry-themed gifts & novelties," including a t-shirt saying "Your Undertaker Is The Last Person Who Will Ever Let You Down" for a $1 sale price.

The day-after-Thanksgiving sale started at a minute past midnight...

Avoiding sticker shock at the end

From the AARP: Avoid Long-term Care Sticker Shock. This short item on their website includes a link to a very useful Idaho Guide to Long-term Care services and insurance prices downloadable as a PDF, or with instructions to have a free copy mailed to you. (July 12, 2010)

Religion and end-of-life care

An April 30, 2010 Reader's View in the Idaho Statesman from Sally Jeffcoat, President and CEO of Saint Alphonsus Health System (comprising Saint Al's in Boise, Mercy Medical Center in Nampa, Holy Rosary Medical Center in Ontario, Oregon, and St. Elizabeth Health Services in Baker City, Oregon) responds to concerns that the Catholic "Directive 58" might override patients' expressed wishes for end-of-life care.

Some of what can go wrong when you prepay

The FCA and its affiliates advise against pre-paying for funeral services in most instances. This Feb. 16, 2010 article from the Honolulu Advertiser illustrates a pitfall.

While officials "assure all customers that their contracts... will be fully honored," some of the trust fund investments have lost 85% or more of their value, and auditors said many of the records have been lost or destroyed. The audit of RightStar's books filed in Circuit Court states that "trust funds maintained for the benefit of some 50,000 customers are $22,621,567 below legal requirements."

Simpler burial in Fort Collins

Fort Collins has set aside a 1 acre section of a city cemetery for people to be buried without a vault or embalming. Simple. John Young provides the commentary on "old-fashioned" burial becoming new again. (Oct. 14, 2009)

Home funerals discussed on Talk of the Nation

NPR's "Talk of the Nation" had a discussion with Max Alexander, author of the March Smithsonian Magazine piece (below); Lisa Carlson, author of Caring for the Dead; and Glenn Taylor, owner of Glenn Funeral Home and Crematory in Kentucky, on April 30, 2009: In Home Funerals, Families Care For Their Dead.

Funeral business affected by recession too

Dana Milbank reports in the Washington Post that the funeral business is not immune from recession: Funeral Business Feeling Six Feet Under. The accompanying video from the National Funeral Directors Association annual meeting is not to be missed.
(April 1, 2009)

And in the same vein... we also recommend the Alfred Hitchcock Presents episode, Six People, No Music. Timeless.

The satisfaction of a home funeral (Smithsonian Magazine)

When his father and father-in-law died within days of each other, author Max Alexander learned a great deal about the funeral industry: The Surprising Satisfactions of a Home Funeral.
(March, 2009 Smithsonian Magazine)

Mind-boggling ordinance in Georgia

Georgia County Bans Green Burial - FCA Responds: "(C)ounty Commissioners caved to unfounded fears and wrote the most mind-bogglingly bad, evidence-free cemetery ordinance we've ever seen." Among other things, the new law requires "leak-proof" caskets and vaults, a category of products that doesn't exist. (The Federal Trade Commission's Funeral Rule and Georgia state law both bar funeral directors from misrepresenting the "preservative" qualities of burial boxes.) (Jan. 4, 2009)

Environmentally-friendly burial practices

This ABC News story, Green Graveyards Offer Burial Without a Trace describes some of the possibilities for environmentally-friendly burial practices. Author Mark Harris, whose book Grave Matters is now available in paperback, is featured. (Dec. 7, 2008)

Green burial in Camas, WA

The Fern Prairie Cemetery (north of Camas, Washington) began offering a "green burial" option, thanks to a customer asking if it was possible.

The Undertaking (and the lawsuit)

FRONTLINE's The Undertaking aired on Idaho Public TV on October 30, 2007 and can now be viewed via that link to the PBS website. The film "enters the world of Thomas Lynch, a writer, poet and undertaker whose family for three generations has cared for both the living and the dead in a small Michigan town. Through the intimate stories of families coming to terms with grief, mortality, and a funeral's rituals, it illuminates the heartbreak and beauty in the journey taken between the living and the dead when a loved one dies."

Our fall 2007 newsletter had responses to the film from member Jeanette Ross, and from Lisa Carlson, author and Executive Director of the Funeral Ethics Organization.

Mr. Lynch had his own response: he sued us! That conclusion of the story from our point of view was in the spring 2010 newsletter: The Thomas Lynch Affair.

Funeral planning simplified

A brochure from the national FCA provides "Where to Start When you Don't Know How to Start": Four-Step Funeral Planning (also available as a PDF document/tri-fold brochure).

Green funerals on Fresh Air

Terry Gross talked to author Mark Harris on Fresh Air, Jan. 22, 2007, on the topic of Environmentally Friendly Funerals. Harris is a former environmental columnist with the LA Times Syndicate, and author of the book Grave Matters: A Journey Through the Modern Funeral Industry to a Natural Way of Burial.

TMI? Life after life

Life after life in the Oct. 22, 2006 Twin Falls Times-News described some of the possibilities for what happens to your body when you die. Reader comments included helpful additional information, and a number from people who apparently would rather not know. "Needless information," "grossest," and "horrible" were some of the reactions.

Remembering the dear departed

Tom Chiarella's advice on How to Give a Eulogy, in the Sept. 2006 Esquire.

Baby boomers going out in style

It's My Funeral and I'll Serve Ice Cream if I Want To, by John Leland, in the July 20, 2006 New York Times.

"As members of the baby boom generation plan final services for their parents or themselves, they bring new consumer expectations and fewer attachments to churches, traditions or organ music—forcing funeral directors to be more like party planners, and inviting some party planners to test the farewell waters."

Interesting statistic from the article: it says 2 million Americans each year are "buried" by funeral homes (I expect this includes those cremated), "at a price tag of $13 billion." That's $6,500, on average, nearly ten times the FCAI member price for minimal services from our cooperating mortuary.

Idaho casket makers featured

Bannock Pride casket-makers Marcia Racehorse-Robles and Dave Robles were featured in the summer 2006 Idaho Arts Quarterly from Boise Weekly. The story describes the efforts to reclaim traditional funeral practices, as well as their artistry.

Isn't there a greener way to go?

This Madison, Wis. Isthmus article responds to the "growing concern about the sustainability of current cemetery practices and growing interest in a return to the simpler burial practices of the 19th century, the unadorned pine box and a simple rock for a headstone."

One estimate is that "827,060 gallons of embalming fluid are buried in the U.S. each year," along with "many tons of reinforced concrete, steel, copper, bronze and hardwoods.

Why didn't they embalm the Pope?

Slate's "Explainer" asks Why Didn't They Embalm the Pope? It doesn't provide an answer, but it does describe the basics of the process.

You may be surprised to learn that the U.S. and Canada are the only countries in the world that routinely practice embalming these days. It's just a custom, and not required by law.

Autopsies increasingly rare

The New York Times Magazine article, Buried Answers by David Dobbs discusses the decrease in the rate of performing autopsies and the arguments for increasing the practice. Hospitals used to autopsy almost half of the people who died in their care. Now the rate is below 5%.

"(N)umerous studies over the last century have found that in 25 to 40 percent of cases in which an autopsy is done, it reveals an undiagnosed cause of death. Because of those errors, in 7 to 12 percent of the cases, treatment that might have been lifesaving wasn't prescribed. (In the other cases, the disease might have advanced beyond treatment or there might have been multiple causes of death.)" –Apr. 24, 2005